Hadith Reflection 6: When Praise Becomes the Purpose

A reflection by Imam Abdullah Hasan, Finchley Mosque.

This is the first reflection in the Admonitions – Warning Against Showing Off section of al-Targhib wa al-Tarhib.

عَنْ جُنْدُبِ بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، قَالَ: قَالَ النَّبِيُّ ﷺ:

«مَنْ سَمَّعَ سَمَّعَ اللَّهُ بِهِ، وَمَنْ يُرَائِي يُرَائِي اللَّهُ بِهِ»

Jundub ibn ʿAbdullah رضي الله عنهما reported that the Prophet ﷺ said:

“Whoever makes his good deeds known so that people will praise him, Allah will expose what he intended. And whoever performs good deeds for people to see and praise him, Allah will expose what he intended.”

Source

Sahih al-Bukhari, 6499; Sahih Muslim, 2987.

This Hadith contains a serious warning against riyāʾ (الرِّيَاء), showing off in acts of worship or good deeds in order to be seen, admired, or praised by people. It also warns against tasmiʿ (التَّسْمِيع), making one’s good deeds known or spoken about so that people will hear of them and respond with admiration.

The Prophet ﷺ uses two closely related expressions: مَنْ سَمَّعَ سَمَّعَ اللَّهُ بِهِ and مَنْ يُرَائِي يُرَائِي اللَّهُ بِهِ. The first is connected with making one’s deeds heard, while the second comes from riyāʾ, which is related to being seen. Together, they describe a person whose outward goodness is being shaped by the desire for recognition.

The warning is therefore not simply about whether an action is visible to other people. A good deed performed publicly is not automatically riyāʾ. There are many circumstances in which good deeds need to be visible: teaching others, encouraging people towards goodness, organising charitable work, leading prayer, supporting a community, or setting an example. What matters is the intention behind the action.

Likewise, a person may feel pleased when someone appreciates something good they have done. The mere experience of being happy about praise does not, by itself, mean that the deed was performed for riyāʾ. The deeper question is: What was the purpose of the deed, and what place does the praise of people occupy in the heart?

The Hadith directs our attention towards something that other people cannot see: the intention behind the action. A person may appear generous, devoted, knowledgeable, charitable or religious, while the hidden motive may be the desire to be admired. Conversely, a person may perform an apparently small and unnoticed act purely for Allah, and that hidden sincerity may be more valuable than what people see.

The warning is therefore deeply connected with the unseen life of the heart.

What Does the Hadith Mean?

The Hadith warns the believer against allowing the desire for people’s admiration to become the reason for doing good.

A person may begin with a sincere intention, but gradually become increasingly concerned with how the deed appears to others. The action may remain outwardly good, yet the heart can become attached to recognition. The person is no longer simply asking, “Is this pleasing to Allah?” but also, perhaps more importantly, “Will people notice? What will they think of me? Will they praise me?”

The Prophet ﷺ warns that what is hidden from people is not hidden from Allah. A person may carefully manage an outward image, but Allah knows the intention beneath it.

This makes riyāʾ particularly subtle. It is not necessarily found in obviously boastful behaviour. It can enter quietly through the desire to be noticed, the disappointment when nobody acknowledges an effort, or the temptation to make a good deed known because recognition feels rewarding.

The cure is not to abandon good deeds because other people might see them. Rather, it is to continually return the heart to Allah and ask whom the deed is ultimately for.

Lessons and Takeaways

  1. A good deed can be outwardly impressive while its true value depends upon the intention behind it. We should therefore give attention not only to what we do, but also to why we are doing it.
  2. Being seen is not the same as showing off. Some good deeds are necessarily public, and visibility alone does not make an action insincere. The question is what the heart is seeking through that visibility.
  3. Praise is not the enemy; dependence upon praise is the danger. We can appreciate encouragement from others without making their approval the measure of our worth or the reason for our goodness.
  4. Private goodness can strengthen sincerity. When we regularly do things that nobody else knows about, we create opportunities to practise doing good for Allah rather than for an audience.
  5. We cannot control other people’s opinions, but we can work on our own intentions. Our responsibility lies in repeatedly bringing our motives back to what is pleasing to Allah.
  6. Self-examination should lead to correction, not self-condemnation. If we discover an unhealthy desire for recognition within ourselves, the appropriate response is to acknowledge it, renew our intention and continue striving towards sincerity.
  7. A useful measure of sincerity is what remains when recognition is removed. If nobody knew, nobody thanked us and nobody praised us, would we still believe that the deed was worth doing?
  8. The safest place for some good deeds is where only Allah knows about them. Not every act of goodness needs to become part of our public identity

Join the daily hadith lesson

The hadith lesson takes place every day after Dhuhr at Finchley Mosque, 683–685 High Road, North Finchley, London N12 0DA. Everyone is welcome – come along, listen and reflect with us.

Next week: Hadith Reflection 7 – When Worship Becomes a Performance.

Found this beneficial? Share it with family and friends – and follow us @finchleymosque for each new reflection.

Recent Posts

Archives